Compare

The Car Insurance Guide

Overall Personalized Rating: 4.3/5 (Very Good)

Summary

If you are interested in looking at prices from a variety of carriers and want a self-driven, legitimate approach to selecting auto insurance, then Compare.com could be the site for you. Compare.com is an insurance comparison site with rates from over 60 insurers. Just put in your information and Compare will show you the rates from many different carriers.

Key Benefits

Provides rates from some major carriers and many carriers that do not have their own direct to consumer process
Compare up to 60 insurance brands online, many of which providing pricing information
Auto Insurance comparison available in every continental state

Ratings Summary

Ratings Highlights

Overall Rating

Compare insurance is an online marketplace for carriers who are less well known. Carriers that are typically regional in nature.

Pricing

As multiple companies are reviewed, consumers are in the driver's seat. They can choose a competitive price from Compare's panel of auto insurance companies.

Handling Claims

Claims proficiency will be dependent on the ultimate carrier chosen.

Uninsured Drivers

Many carriers mean more options for consumers, and therefore good options for those that are uninsured.

Young Drivers

Many carriers mean more options for consumers, and therefore good options for those that are young.

Bundling Auto with Other Insurance Types

Many carriers mean more options for consumers, and therefore good options for those that are bundling.

Drivers with Tickets/Accidents

Many carriers mean more options for consumers, and therefore good options for those that are bad drivers.

Premium Driver

Many carriers mean more options for consumers, and therefore good options for those that are premium drivers. Our pricing research found Compare's panel of auto insurance companies to offer some competitive rates for experienced drivers with clean driving records.

Company Background

Launched in 2013, Compare.com is a car insurance comparison site with rates from over 60 insurers. Compare was modeled after Confused.com, which is a major auto insurance buying website in England. Compare.com is headquartered in Richmond, Virginia and has about a hundred employees. Compare.com's parent company is the Admiral Group, Plc, a British insurance company.

The Car Insurance Guide's Reviews Methodology

The Car Insurance Guide uses a proprietary algorithm to evaluate the car insurance options presented. Factors reviewed and rated include pricing, handling of claims, age of driver, bundling, and driver type. These factors are evaluated and scored to provide an overall score for the carrier as well as being individually assessed to provide a detailed review of the fit of the carrier to the driver. The data comes from research The Car Insurance Guide conducts as an invite-only annual survey and from interviews with car insurance agents. Insights from experts, those whose job it is to understand and recommend the best insurance companies for their clients, is invaluable. Use of The Car Insurance Guide's 2025 reviews by third parties without the express written consent of The Car Insurance Guide is strictly prohibited.